Skip to content

Source Code Audit & Recommendations

This page summarizes a focused code review of the go-observability core sources and presents actionable recommendations to improve robustness, security, and operability.

What I reviewed

  • config.go, logger.go, otel.go, gin_middleware.go, grpc_interceptor.go, metadata.go and README examples.

Findings & Recommendations

  1. Metrics & Tracing exporters default to WithInsecure()
  2. Finding: OTLP exporters are initialized with WithInsecure().

  3. Recommendation: Add configuration flags to opt into TLS, custom certs, or securely provisioned endpoints in production.

  4. Internal metrics server uses fmt.Printf for errors

  5. Finding: The Prometheus metrics server logs errors with fmt.Printf.

  6. Recommendation: Use the library Logger (or accept a logger) to keep logs consistent and structured.

  7. Validation could be more explicit / tested

  8. Finding: finalizeAndValidate() uses reflection and returns generic errors for misconfiguration.

  9. Recommendation: Add explicit unit tests for validation paths and consider returning typed/config-specific errors for better programmatic handling.

  10. Graceful shutdown ergonomics

  11. Finding: InitOtel returns a shutdown function but callers should provide a context with timeout.

  12. Recommendation: Document best-practice shutdown sequence (context with timeout) and consider adding a helper that accepts a timeout parameter.

  13. Documentation & examples

  14. Finding: README contains extensive examples; docs site should mirror them and provide runnable commands.

  15. Recommendation: Generate API reference (mkdocstrings or godoc -> markdown) and include runnable snippets for pull, push, and hybrid modes.

  16. ObservabilityMiddlewareConfig behavior

  17. Finding: SkipRoute predicate takes precedence over ExcludedPaths, which is reasonable but should be highlighted in docs.
  18. Recommendation: Document examples and edge-cases (e.g., prefix matching, regex-based skipping) or provide helpers for common patterns.

Suggested immediate changes (low effort, high impact)

  • Replace internal fmt.Printf calls with logger usage.
  • Add METRICS_TLS_ENABLED / OTEL_TLS env flags (or reuse OTEL_* conventions) for exporter security.
  • Add a small test suite for finalizeAndValidate() covering invalid METRICS_MODE, missing SERVICE_NAME, and invalid LOG_LEVEL.
  • Add mkdocstrings to mkdocs.yml to auto-generate API docs from Go sources (or add a script to generate markdown via godoc).

Next steps for docs enrichment

  • Auto-generate API reference for public types and functions.
  • Add step-by-step migration examples for pull, push, and hybrid metrics modes with docker-compose snippets.
  • Add a section for production hardening and security considerations (TLS, auth, endpoints).

If you want, I can open PR patches to implement the low-effort fixes above (logger usage and adding TLS flags), and add unit tests for validation.